Hi guest, Register | Login | Contact Us
Welcome to Phayul.com - Our News Your Views
Wed 07, Oct 2015 09:13 PM (IST)
Search:     powered by Google
Photo News
Statements &
Press Releases

Book Reviews
Movie Reviews
News Discussions
News Archives
Download photos from Tibet
 Latest Stories
Dharamshala LEC extends voter registration deadline till Oct 9
Local NGO champions eradication of rabies from Dharamshala
Three more lone protesters detained in Ngaba
PM Sangay officially announces his candidacy for 2016 elections
Tanshuman Gurung crowned Miss Himalaya 2015
Tibetan prisoner released in severe medical condition
Tibetan woman hit by car in Minnesota, dies
Dalai Lama on his health: No worries, stay assured
Police takes TYC hunger striker to hospital against will
Copenhagen Police to investigate suppression of Tibetan flag
Readers' Comments on "Tibetan Parliament changes 'Kalon Tripa' to 'Sikyong'"
The Tibetan Parliament-in-Exile today unanimously adopted a resolution to change the official title of the head of the Dharamshala based Central Tibetan Administration from “Kalon Tripa” to “Sikyong.” Kalon Tripa, in English has been referred to as ‘Chief of Cabinet’ while the new title, Sikyong, translates to ‘Political Leader.’ ...
 Click here to post your comment
9 comment(s) found You are on page 1 of 1

Location: US
Subject: what's in a name?
Sep 26 2012 08:28 AM

In the end what HE does & accomplishes will count and not by what title he answerrrs to.

Location: MTilla
Subject: Get rid of ignorance & fear
Sep 24 2012 10:09 PM

"While HE is alive, we need to pave way for a smooth transition to a more honest,people- responsible functional democracy free from of the shackle of family hegemonistic rule."

You got that right. Same family hegemonic rule claim to give ‘protection’ to certain ignorant groups-monastics included. Is this a way to function in this modern world.? Why do we need bosses for ‘protection’? People should be free of such shackles & function openly and honestly. This is Eventually taking HHDL & these people for a ride.

Location: Madison
Subject: Sikyong
Sep 24 2012 10:04 PM

If Sikyong is an interum title, which it was in the cases of Reting and Taktra in the absense of a leader, it sounds like we are waiting for another leader to take over.

Location: MT
Subject: What is in a name if the real change doe not come.
Sep 23 2012 10:42 AM

The Chithue could not agree to ammend the term" Kalon Tripa" to " Sokyong" during the last session as if the change of the connotation has a huge political significance. Nil. They waste time like that.

Academically, what is in a name. The last Prime Minister of Independent Tibet- Lhukangapa - was known as a Silon( Political Minister ) of Tibet. In post 1959 Gaden Phodrang, they changed the term, to " Kalon Tripa" ( the Throne Occupier of the Cabinet". Did the change make any difference? What is wrong/right if we change to " Sikyong"?

The term Sikying is NOT translated as a Political leader, akin to PL in 22 establishment.Wrong. Srid means Political, but but sKyong does not mean leader- itmeans Administrator.And this term is not being coined now. It was always there used. The term was used as title confered on the Head of the Regency period in the absence or minor age of the Dalai Lama.

Anyway: Whether we have a,Silon, a Katri or a Sidkyong, for a while the Dalai Lama has become indespensible. While HE is alive, we need to pave way for a smooth transition to a more honest,people- responsible functinal democracy free from of the shackle of family hegemonistic rule. This is easier said than done. The traditional leaders and families who have taken the people and even HHDL for a big ride need to make way for CHANGE. I pinned lots of Hope in Lobsang Senge la- I wish him Best. Atleast he can start the change.


Location: nyc, usa
Subject: 50%
Sep 22 2012 12:59 AM

The title is 50% accurate. Sangye is political, however I see no evidence of him leading in any worthwhile fashion.

Look, we all know that Sangye got elected by the least educated, least experienced members of the Tibetan community.

I've yet to meet a real scholar or activist who voted for him, and though I don't have an immense number of contacts, I probably have enough of a representative sampling to say that very few people with a deep background in Tibetan politics thought Sangye was the best choice. But Americans do the same thing, sometimes.

I recently told some Tibetans I was very close to "Sangye has not demonstrated either a plan, or a timeframe to achieve his proposed autonomy. That is not leadership. If he does those two things, I would not only respect him, I would even be willing to prostrate."

And this, despite my support for Rangzen. Tibet and Tibetans need realistic leadership that badly.

Fortunately for my ego, I doubt I'll be prostrating to Lobsang Sangye anytime soon.

I am sure he is a nice man, and I wish him the best. But if you've read the lives of people from Gandhi, to Oscar Romero, to Michael Collins....people who created political change....Sangye's position and approach would not even merit a footnote in a book on political leadership.

I do suggest the Tibetan people break with the traditional deference to authority, and demand that their "Sikyong" produce.

I hope that in the "Year 2" progress report, there will be enough progress on occupied Tibet to merit more than a few lame, and vague sentences.

Bhod gyal lo!

Location: Bhutan
Subject: Tibetan Equivalent for Prime Minister
Sep 21 2012 05:35 PM

The Kashag(Cabinet) of the CTA could have even adopted the Tibetan equivalent for the Prime Minister as " Lyonchen" as we refer to here in Bhutan. Just my opinion.

Location: Toronto
Subject: Let's stop pretending
Sep 20 2012 10:52 PM

It doesn’t matter to me what you call the holder of that office. The question is does he or she really has any real political power that was devolved from the top. And if not, why are we pretending as if he does.

Location: Madison
Subject: Welcome
Sep 20 2012 10:24 PM

This is a welcome change and a good title in Tibetan; however, the English title, Political Leader is not worthy of the dignity of the highest office. I knew somebody whose title was political leader in the 22 Establishment. We all need to brainstrom to come up with a better title in English. Sikyong Taktra is commonly known as Regent in Western refrences to his position. I hope somebody will come up with an idea sooner than later to replace, political leader.

Location: Toronto
Subject: Re
Sep 20 2012 07:09 PM

interesting development
 Latest Topics
We encourage China to engage with Dalai Lama : Obama (19:09, 28 Sep 2015)
11 arrested for reclaiming land in Dzoege County (18:09, 28 Sep 2015)
RANGZEN SPRING II (12:08, 21 Aug 2015)
Tibetan PM launches MWA documentary, app for Tibet Online TV (20:08, 17 Aug 2015)
EC in limbo as CTA, PM candidate engage in public spat (22:08, 06 Aug 2015)
  Hot Topics
Tibetan PM launches MWA documentary, app for Tibet Online TV (1)
We encourage China to engage with Dalai Lama : Obama (1)
11 arrested for reclaiming land in Dzoege County (1)
34th Kalachakra postponed to 2017 (0)
Exile Tibetan PM Lob.. (0)
Tashi Topgyal makes it five in the race for Tibetan PM's post (0)
Tibetan woman dies of self immolation in Sangchu County (0)
Why Dr. Lobsang Sangay Again? (0)
Tibet never a part of China but Middle Way still a viable solution, says CTA (0)
Miss Tibet 2014 to represent Tibet at Mannapuram Miss Asia pageant (0)
Interesting correspondence between the Dalai Lama and Nehru (1960) (0)
Student group denied venue for poll debate at TCV Youth Hostel (0)
EC clarifies penalties for violation of election rules (0)
TYC begins indefinite hunger strike in New Delhi (0)
Tibetan activists confront Chinese official at Xi Jinping’s book Launch (0)
Copenhagen Police to investigate suppression of Tibetan flag (0)
IFJ criticizes China over media censorship (0)
Phayul.com does not endorse the advertisements placed on the site. It does not have any control over the google ads. Please send the URL of the ads if found objectionable to editor@phayul.com
Copyright © 2004-2015 Phayul.com   feedback | advertise | contact us
Powered by Lateng Online