Hi guest, Register | Login | Contact Us
Welcome to Phayul.com - Our News Your Views
Sat 26, Jul 2014 04:32 AM (IST)
Search:     powered by Google
 MENU
Home
News
Photo News
Opinions
Statements &
Press Releases

Book Reviews
Movie Reviews
Interviews
Travels
Health
Obituaries
News Discussions
News Archives
Download photos from Tibet
 Latest Stories
Lhasa - Shigatse rail line operational from August
Tibetan exiles commemorate 100 years of Shimla Convention
Violence in Gaza "unthinkable", says the Dalai Lama
Tibetan commerce body holds two-day workshop for young entrepreneurs
Reports of Dalai Lama being unwell not true, says a close aide
Tibetan legislators lobby Indian MPs for Tibet
Three Tibetans arrested in Sog County
Tibetan monk commits suicide in protest against religious repression
Chinese activist Hu Jia beaten up by 'plain clothed men'
Tibetan monk freed after serving sentence
 Latest Photo News
Monks repairing road leading towards Tsuglakhang before the arrival of the Tibetan leader His Holiness the Dalai Lama from New Delhi. Incessant rain has caused the roads to wear out leaving huge potholes often leading to accidents. July 21, 2014/Phayul Photo/Kunsang Gashon
7 Petitioners lie on the pavement outside offices of China Youth Daily, after they drank pesticides to commit suicide. 12 people are being treated in hospitals after two separate incidents of mass suicide bids to publicize forced acquisition of land by government/16-7-2014, Telegraph
Incessant rain in Tibet's capital Lhasa has led to flooding in various parts of the city, including the sacred Jhokhang Temple/Photo/Lhasa Sonam's FB page
more photos »
Advertisement
DR. LOBSANG SANGAY'S RESPONSE TO JAMYANG NORBU'S PIECE
By Email[Monday, October 18, 2010 10:13]
It was good to read Jamyang Norbu la's article on the Upcoming Kalon Tripa Election and I look forward to reading his commentary on the other candidates as well. I appreciate his defense of Kalon Tripa candidates' honesty and experience against criticism made by a panelist on VOA Kunleng TV.

I am also of the view that all the candidates are dedicated and patriotic Tibetans who want to serve the cause. Now let me address some of the issues raised by him about me.

I found Jamyang la's analysis to be way off mark. The statement "I want to be Obama of China", was a JOKE and not meant to be taken seriously. In October 2008, at the time of the conference, there was an excitement about the real possibility that Obama from a marginalized group might be elected as the President of America. In contrast, it was impossible to imagine a Tibetan becoming the President of PRC. Four other attendees (Dr. Warren Smith, Dr. Sonam Topgyal, Tashi Rabgey, and another American) recalled this joking remark and said they had a good laugh. As Jamyang la was not at the conference, I don't blame him for the out-of-context interpretation. However, he should have fact-checked with other attendees instead of relying on a panelist without sense of humor. (1)

Jamyang la's interpretation of my views on the Chinese constitution is alarmist to say the least because it makes me sound as though I am a believer of the Chinese constitution. On the contrary, I have strongly criticized the Chinese constitution and particularly the Regional National Autonomy Law. (Please see the article published by Harvard South Asian journal)

The criticism of the Chinese constitution was acknowledged and quoted by Human Rights Watch report on China and Tibet (2005) and also in an article by Tenzing Sonam (Producer and director of Sun Behind the Clouds). Jamyang la bases his comments on his recollection of our conversation during his time in Boston, perhaps my paper, published in the Harvard Asia Quarterly in the Summer of 1999, could refresh his memory.

He also claims that I dismiss the debate about 'Umey Lam' and 'Rangzen' which is untrue. My objection is against extreme rhetoric on both sides by Rangzen and Umey Lam supporters, which I find unhealthy and divisive. I do believe that any action has to be based on unity, planning and discipline, three cardinal principles of non-violent movement. For detail on this issue, please go to: http://www.phayul.com/news/article.aspx?id=23208


---------------------

1. The panel consisted of Elliot Sperling from Indiana University, Allen Carlson from Cornell University and myself, and the moderator was Mark Mohr, Director of the Asia Program of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars.


The views expressed in this piece are that of the author and the publication of the piece on this website does not necessarily reflect their endorsement by the website.
Print Send Bookmark and Share
  Readers' Comments »
Point Totally MIssed (Ghalib)
Lobsang Sangay’s response (zosash)
A Response to Lobsang Sangay's Response (zosash)
jamyang is big joker!! (kdhondup)
that's response? (gendunchopal)
Jamyang is a joker!! (kdhondup)
waiting for it... (ugyanc)
Katri (Bodrig)
@ fiftynine (ring)
Let's all be civil (wds1)
Game on !!!!! (tibetusa)
I support for any type of criticism. (fiftynine)
Empty vessel makes much noise... (tagabhurung)
too early (Meeyul)
Stance. (tensherap)
a runaway joke (klash)
Joke? (tenzintenzintenzin)
too defensive and immature (phuntsok12)
Hidden Agenda of Jamyang Poola (tseshoe)
Thanks...! (boemi)
Constructive criticism is welcomed (lhaksam2010)
Learn more on leadership qualities. (fiftynine)
Too Early... (tibet4ever)
** Thouch a shit, U smell shit ** (nijee)
Thanks for the clearance (Futuregeneration)
Your Comments

 Other Stories
Tibetan author of banned video released, slapped conditions
Knitters warm hearts in Tibet
Tibetans protest against acquisition of Gyama mine by Canadian company
Dalai Lama: Chinese Censorship 'Immoral'
DR. LOBSANG SANGAY'S RESPONSE TO JAMYANG NORBU'S PIECE
Advertisement
Advertisement
Photo Galleries
Advertisement
Phayul.com does not endorse the advertisements placed on the site. It does not have any control over the google ads. Please send the URL of the ads if found objectionable to editor@phayul.com
Copyright © 2004-2014 Phayul.com   feedback | advertise | contact us
Powered by Lateng Online
Advertisement