Hi guest, Register | Login | Contact Us
Welcome to Phayul.com - Our News Your Views
Sat 21, Sep 2019 03:07 PM (IST)
Search:     powered by Google
Photo News
Statements &
Press Releases

Book Reviews
Movie Reviews
News Discussions
News Archives
Download photos from Tibet
 Latest Stories
Modern material-oriented education leads to dependence on alcohol, drugs and suicide when emotion flares: His Holiness the Dalai Lama
China urges US to stop pushing bill on Tibet that "undermines" China’s Dalai Lama claim
Dalai Lama leaves for Delhi, Mathura for public engagements
International Economics of Happiness Conference comes to Ladakh to address development challenges
German parliamentary delegation calls on Dalai Lama, visits CTA
Chinese Prof. echoes how China’s national park system ignored the important role of local residents
Revised TPA bill proposes sanction on Chinese official impeding Dalai Lama’s reincarnation
“I commend India for its deeply rooted religious pluralism,” Dalai Lama's in birthday wishes for Modi
Tribals in Odisha seek cancellation of Tibetan refugees’ land lease
Bill to modify Tibet policy Act 2002 introduced in US House of Representatives
 Latest Photo News
Nearly 3000 Students from eight countries listened to teachings of His Holiness the Dalai Lama. Three day annual teachings for youth began today. June 3, 2019. Phayul Photo: Kunsang Gashon
His Holiness the Dalai Lama is being escorted to the teaching site at Tsuglakhang temple, May 13, 2019. Phayul Photo: Kunsang Gashon
More than a thousand Tibetans, Uyghurs and supporters protest in Paris to denounce China's repression in Tibet. Xi Jinping will be on an official visit to France from Monday. Under a canopy of flags with snow lions, protesters marched from the Trocadero Human Rights Square to the Peace Wall at the other end of the Champ de Mars. 25 March 2019. Phayul photo/Norbu Wangyal
more photos »
Spain reins in crusading
BBC[Friday, June 26, 2009 17:19]
By Steve Kingstone

For more than a decade, a drab, beige building in central Madrid has been the global destination of choice for anyone wanting to file allegations of genocide, torture and crimes against humanity.

The Audiencia Nacional - National Criminal Court - has heard complaints of human-rights abuses as far afield as Guatemala, Rwanda, Chile, Tibet, Gaza and Guantanamo Bay.

Currently, 10 cases from five continents are being investigated by Spanish judges, under the principle of "universal jurisdiction," which holds that some crimes are so grave that they can be tried anywhere, regardless of where the offences were committed.

In a recent statement, almost 100 organisations collectively praised Spain's "pioneering approach," gushing that the country "should feel proud of itself" for becoming a reference point for other nations.

Except, Spain's left-leaning government sees things rather differently.

In parliament, it is sponsoring a controversial change in the law, which would limit the future scope of universal jurisdiction to cases in which (i) the victims are Spanish, (ii) the alleged perpetrators are in Spain, or (iii) some other clear link to Spain can be demonstrated.

On Thursday, the proposal was approved by lawmakers in the lower house by an overwhelming 341-2 vote, with three abstentions. Senate approval is seen as a formality.

'Enormous backwards step'

"Universal jurisdiction doesn't necessarily work," argues Angel Lossada, Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, explaining the government's policy.

"Without a connection to Spain, it presents problems of obtaining proof and co-operation from other states. And then the cases do not conclude."

He has a point. All too often, inquiries by the Audiencia Nacional have produced complex legal arguments with the states concerned, filling pages of court documents but rarely the dock.

Only Rodolfo Scilingo, an Argentine former naval officer, has been convicted in Spain under universal jurisdiction - although the court's defenders point out that a second Argentine, Ricardo Cavallo, was extradited from Spain to face trial back home.

The government's approach has appalled campaigners who argue that, with or without convictions, the Audiencia Nacional has commendably shed light on dark acts committed by closed regimes.

The campaigners include witnesses from the most famous case of all - the attempt by Judge Baltasar Garzon to extradite Chile's Augusto Pinochet on murder charges in 1998.

"For me, the Pinochet case was a triumph of justice - together with Nuremberg, it was the most important international prosecution of the past 100 years," explains Laura Gonzalez Vera, whose husband was murdered by the general's secret police.

"In Chile, the killers are still protected by an amnesty law, but the investigation in Spain destroyed Pinochet politically."

Another key witness, Oscar Soto Guzman, was the personal physician of Salvador Allende, the elected left-wing president who committed suicide when Pinochet's troops stormed his official residence in September 1973.

The doctor is deeply critical of the government's plan to change the law.

"It's a move which completely contradicts everything that's happened up until now," he says.

"We went legitimately through the Spanish courts to take the Pinochet case forward, but this is an enormous backwards step."


In common with the human rights lobby, Mr Guzman accuses the politicians of acting out of political motives.

"For the government of the day, I suppose it's more comfortable to forget the past and avoid diplomatic problems. There have been very strong international pressures in these cases - above all, from Israel."

Israel's intervention, in January, followed the opening of an inquiry by the Audiencia Nacional into a bombing raid on Gaza in 2002, which targeted a known Palestinian militant but also killed 14 civilians.

Seven Israelis - a mix of politicians, officials and military officers - were accused of crimes against humanity.

In a statement, the Israeli government branded the inquiry in Madrid "unacceptable," while the then Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni told her Spanish counterpart the killings were already under investigation in Israel.

Soon afterwards, Madrid confirmed that the law on universal jurisdiction would be changed.

"The Spanish foreign minister was scared," alleges Gonzalo Boye, the lawyer who filed the complaint against Israel.

"This is the wrong concept of foreign relations. Instead of dealing as equals, they are dealing from a position of submission to countries which are protecting war criminals."

Mr Boye claims that ongoing cases against China (Tibet) and lawyers for the Bush administration (Guantanamo Bay) added to the government's desire to put a stop to such diplomatically-sensitive probes in future.

But the foreign ministry strongly denies caving in to the concerns of heavyweight governments.

"This is not about pressure from one country or another, but rather it's about deciding the best role for Spain in tackling impunity," insists Mr Lossada.

Pointing out that the current Spanish rules predate the International Criminal Court (ICC) and regional tribunals, Mr Lossada argues that "today, there are a lot of international instruments that are more efficient and more consensual" than pursuing such cases in Madrid.

However, the ICC can only prosecute cases dating from after its inception in 2002.

Whatever its motives, the government has won quiet praise from some of the countries directly affected.

"This change will be helpful to the Spanish government," says Irit Kohn, a veteran Israeli lawyer. "It will have a filter effect, and provide restraint in cases which are politically motivated."

An official from another influential nation agrees that the move is "understandable", likening sensitive cases at the Audiencia Nacional "to an 800lb gorilla in the room" of bilateral relations.

The new law is not expected to be retroactive - meaning that high-profile existing cases will continue.

But nonetheless, human-rights groups were quick to denounce Thursday's parliamentary vote as a cynical ploy by politicians to rein in Spain's crusading judiciary.

In a statement, Amnesty International wrote: "A clear message has been sent out, that Spain is more concerned with not offending certain powerful governments than with ending the impunity enjoyed by criminals."
Print Send Bookmark and Share
  Readers' Comments »
Spain should stand up for human rights (wds1)
Your Comments

 Other Stories
Tibetan exiles ask China to “Stop Torture in Tibet”
Spain reins in crusading
Nepal police arrest Tibetan protesters near Tibet border: Update
Photo Galleries
Phayul.com does not endorse the advertisements placed on the site. It does not have any control over the google ads. Please send the URL of the ads if found objectionable to editor@phayul.com
Copyright © 2004-2019 Phayul.com   feedback | advertise | contact us
Powered by Lateng Online