Hi guest, Register | Login | Contact Us
Welcome to Phayul.com - Our News Your Views
Wed 19, Dec 2018 08:48 AM (IST)
Search:     powered by Google
Photo News
Statements &
Press Releases

Book Reviews
Movie Reviews
News Discussions
News Archives
Download photos from Tibet
 Latest Stories
Tibetan Muslim student group on educational tour in exile capital
Interdependence is the antidote to destructive emotions: Dalai Lama in Bodhgaya
Tibetan man injured in a skirmish with taxi drivers in CTA Compound
Tibetan monk beaten up, arrested in Ngaba for protest
CTA Information Secretary Dhardhon Sharling resigns
Tibetan Prez asked to rewrite the written statement in case no. 20
US Congress passes Reciprocal Access to Tibet Act
Uncle claims nephew died of motorbike fire, not self immolation
Tibetans celebrate 29th year of Nobel peace prize conferment
Youth immolates self in Ngaba
 Latest Photo News
Winner of the Miss Himalaya Pageant 2018 Ritika Sharma, First Runner-up Palak Sharma and Second-Runner-up Ashima Sharma wave to the audience during the Miss Himalaya Pageant 2018 in McLeod Ganj, India, on 6 October 2018, Photo: L. Wangyal
His Holiness the Dalai Lama arrives to begin his four day teaching on the request of a Taiwanese group, Tsuglakhang courtyard, Theckchen Choeling, McLeod Ganj, October . 3, 2018. OHHDL Photo/Ven. Tenzin Jamphel
Tibetan spiritual leader His Holiness the Dalai Lama addresses the gathering during the 50th year celebration of Tibet Insitute Rikon. The event was attended by around 4000 people from all parts of Europe. Around 4000 people have come to attend the function organised by Tibet Institute Rikon with support of Tibetan Community in Switzerland and Liechtensein. Winterthur, September 22, 2018. Phayul photo/Norbu Wangyal
more photos »
China Refuses to Admit Tibet Crackdown to UN Treaty Body
Phayul[Friday, October 24, 2008 22:41]
By Ngawang C. Drakmargyapon
Phayul Special Correspondent

United Nations, Geneva, 24 October - In a written response dated 8 September 2008 to the UN Committee Against Torture (CAT), China denied that hundreds of Tibetans were detained following the Tibetan Uprising and failed to provide “a list of all persons detained” as requested by the Committee in August 2008. “And the notion of ‘dispersing the peaceful demonstrations by monks’ is sheer fabrication” China said in its communication.

This UN expert-body which monitors the full implementation of the UN Convention Against Torture by State-Parties requested a written response from China by stating: “Public statements confirmed that hundreds of persons were detained in connection with the unrest that followed the March 2008 demonstration in the Tibet Autonomous Region and neighbouring Tibetan prefectures and counties in Gansu, Sichuan and Qinghai provinces.”

Taking a position that the 2008 Uprising in Tibet was “not parades and demonstrations”, China told the Committee that “there is no such a thing as “hundreds of people” have been arrested because of these demonstrations.” China response, now available, on the website of the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, then states: “As of July 2008, the justice departments detained 953 persons, among them, 362 persons surrendered themselves to the police; 42 have been convicted and sentenced, and another 116 criminal suspects are under trial according to law.” However, China’s response does not provide any detailed information about the situation of Tibetan detainees outside the “Tibet Autonomous Region”.

CAT had also raised a specific question on the whereabouts of Gedhun Choekyi Nyima, the Eleventh Panchen Lama of Tibet, requesting the Chinese authorities to provide information on this case. In line with its previous statements, the Chinese authorities again avoided a direct answer by simply stating that the Panchen Lama and his family “indicated clearly that in order to keep their normal life from being disturbed, they do not wish to meet with any organization or outsiders. This desire of theirs should be respected.”

At the 41st session which begins on 3 November, the Committee will review China’s Fourth Periodic Report through almost six hours discussions with the Chinese delegation on 7 and 10 November at the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights. When the Committee last reviewed China’s Third Report in May 2000, it expressed concern “about the continuing allegations of serious incidents of torture, especially involving Tibetans and other national minorities ... the absence of a uniform and effective investigation mechanism to examine allegations of torture...”

Apart from studying the China Report, the Committee additionally asked China to “provide information on the reported excessive use of force by the police forces in dispersing the peaceful demonstrations by monks on the 49th anniversary of the exile of the Dalai Lama in March 2008.” While providing a lengthy explanation to this question, China said that “the ‘exile of the Dalai Lama’ is an expression which is out of tune with historical facts.” Denying that excessive force was used by its police, China undermined the Tibetan Uprising by stating: “The incident which happened in Tibet and the neighbouring areas in March this year was not “peaceful demonstration” at all, rather, it was an organized law-breaking serious incident of violence. In the course of handling the case, the law enforcement personnel strictly abided by law and performed their duty of protecting the safety of life and properties of the people, thus “excessive use of force by police” does not exist.

Through these total denials on the ground realities on the Tibetan Plateau, China totally discarded the Committee’s other question such as on the number of Tibetans who lost their lives since March. “It is reported that there were a number of deaths in connection with unrest in the Tibetan Autonomous Region and neighbouring prefectures and counties. Please provide information on any investigation into those deaths and whether there will be a transparent public inquiry into them,” the Committee asked.

Providing no substantive evidence, a politically discriminatory posture of China responded to this question saying: “According to investigation conducted by the department concerned, during the incident on 14 March in Lhasa and other places, the criminal violence committed by law-breakers caused the death of 18 innocent persons who were chopped, smashed or burned to death (among them, 3 were Tibetans), and one law enforcing personnel died a martyr’s death.”

Amnesty International in its submission to the Committee highlighted one Tibetan case of Paltsal Kyab, who died on 26 May 2008, five weeks after he was detained by police. According to eyewitnesses, severe injuries to his body suggest that he died as a result of being tortured in police custody. Similarly, the submissions by the Tibetan Government in Exile and International Campaign for Tibet said that between 140 to 218 Tibetans were killed, died under torture or committed suicide. All these submissions, generally known as Shadow Report from stakeholders are now available on the Committee’s web-link.

New York-based Human Rights in China in its submission stated that China’s classification of State secrets such as “Top Secret”, “Highly Secret” and “Secret” cannot be challenged or appealed. Referring to the Tibetan Uprising, the organization said: “Information about the treatment of persons detained or sentenced in connection with the March 2008 Tibetan demonstrations and information about any investigations into deaths in connection with the March 2008 Tibetan demonstrations are all classified or related to classified information.”

As the Committee Against Torture is scheduled to receive NGO statements on the China Report on 6 November, a strong Tibetan participation is expected, including by the appearance of former-political prisoners like Takna Jigme Sangpo before the body.

It is also expected that the Committee may raise many pertinent questions to the Chinese delegation, including on some of the issues raised in August to which China remained silent. For instance, China avoided the question concerning the Chinese lawyers who received warnings after offering to defend Tibetan detainees with some reportedly refused of license registration.

According to Dharamsala-based Tibetan Centre for Human Rights and Democracy and other monitoring organizations around 100 Tibetans, majority of them political prisoners have died as a result of torture since China ratified the Convention Against Torture on 4 October, 1988. This figure will certainly rise as more reports emerge of custodial deaths due to systematic torture and other cruel methods inflicted on Tibetan detainees since March.

China’s Initial Report was reviewed by the Torture Committee on 27 April 1990 but the unsatisfied Committee asked for an additional report by 31 December 1990 since it found that many of the questions posed to China remained unanswered. In its report to the UN General Assembly in 1990, the Committee said: “It was also noted that the Chinese Government had not hesitated to recognise in its report that torture had yet to be eliminated completely. In that connection, members referred to the numerous allegations of torture in China, particularly in Tibet … and asked what was the Government’s position in that respect. More specifically, questions were put concerning the particular status of Tibet in the People’s Republic of China, the measures adopted to protect the rights of the Tibetan population and, more generally, steps taken to combat torture practice with a view to their final elimination.”

The Committee Against Torture (CAT) is a body of 10 independent experts who hail from Chile, China, Cyprus, Ecuador, Morocco, Norway, Russia, Senegal, Spain and United States of America.

Before the Committee concludes its session on 21 November 2008, it will adopt a concluding observation on China’s Fourth Periodic Report.
Print Send Bookmark and Share
  Readers' Comments »
What to expect! (Tseta)
Your Comments

 Other Stories
China Refuses to Admit Tibet Crackdown to UN Treaty Body
China furious at EU human rights award to 'criminal' dissident Hu Jia
Tibet's Secret Weapon: An Opinion
China keeps its tight grip on Tibetans in provinces
Switzerland expects concrete results from Tibet-China talks: Report
'What Remains of Us': A visit to Tibet, the 'biggest prison in the world'
Norwegian Foreign Secretary Raymond Johansen to Visit Tibet
Photo Galleries
Phayul.com does not endorse the advertisements placed on the site. It does not have any control over the google ads. Please send the URL of the ads if found objectionable to editor@phayul.com
Copyright © 2004-2018 Phayul.com   feedback | advertise | contact us
Powered by Lateng Online